Search FCW


Subscribe Now!
Table of Contents
Sprint
Business
BPM
CXOs
Columns
Columnists
Defense
E-Government
Elections 2008
Enterprise Architecture
Funding
Homeland Security
Health IT
IPv6
LOB
Management
Procurement
Privacy
Policy
Program Management
State and Local
Security
Technology
Telework
Training and Certification
Workforce

More Topics
resourcecenter
Home
Letters to the Editor
Current Issue/Download
Print/Online Archives
Editorial Calendar
researchstore
resourcecenter
Communications for Continuity Operations

Oracle Resource Center
NEW! Transforming Data Center
Managed Services
Service Oriented Architecture
Training & Simulation
Networking Communications
Security Directives and Compliance
Data Center Virtualization
Air Force ELSG Contract Guide

More >>



Latest News
ADVERTISEMENT





 

ACLU: fusion centers need more oversight

By Ben Bain
Published on July 29, 2008

Comment

Click here to comment on this article


Related story links

Fusion Center Update (ACLU)

Suspicious Activity Reporting Guidelines

A new threat, a new institution: The fusion center


Newsletters

You might also be interested in these FCW newsletters:

Daily
Homeland Security
State and Local

To learn more, click here.


Editor's note: This story was updated with additional information on July 31, 2008 at 9:59 a.m. EST.


The extent of data available to authorities through the nationwide network of intelligence fusion centers raises legal and privacy questions that require increased congressional oversight, according to a report released today by the American Civil Liberties Union.  Authorities in those centers have access to numerous intelligence databases.

The civil liberties group said the activities of state and local fusion centers, which the Bush administration identified as the primary way for sharing terrorism related information between state, local and federal authorities, represent part of “a nascent domestic surveillance system.” State and local authorities started forming the centers after the terrorists attacks of September 2001 to upgrade information sharing. The centers are partially funded through grants from the Homeland Security Department.

The ACLU said the use of the centers as a way to pass on suspicious activity reports (SARs) gathered by local authorities and federal efforts to standardize SAR reporting amount to deputizing local and state law enforcement authorities.

Federal authorities have been working to set SAR standards as well as further functional guidance for the centers, which officials say will improve information sharing and protect privacy rights.

However, in a conference call ACLU officials called for Congress to play a greater role in regulating the centers.

National authorities have become increasingly involved — particularly DHS and the FBI, who have officials assigned to many of the centers. There are more than 50 centers in states and major urban areas around the country.

“Rather than letting these fusion centers continue to grow in an organic or ad-hoc way — in a way that can lead to flagrant abuses and violations of rights — Congress really needs to have a debate and discussion and to impose controls,” said Caroline Fredrickson, director of the ACLU Washington Legislative Office.

However, John Cohen, a senior advisor to the Office of the Director of National Intelligence's Program Manager for the Information Sharing Environment (PM-ISE), said authorities in his office and in the Justice Department are in the process of putting out increased guidance and controls to address many of the issues brought up in the ACLU report. The examples used in the report predated these efforts, he said.

“We are building into this process multiple levels of vetting…this comes from training and the development of a standardized approach that is clearly defined to all participants in the system,” Cohen said.

The ACLU said that because activities that could be described as suspicious are “non-criminal" and are often protected by the First Amendment, policing those activities opens the door to “racial profiling and other inappropriate police behavior.”



upcoming event

Program Management Summit 2008, Ronald Reagan Building, Washington, DC
November 18 - November 19, 2008

Defense and Intelligence Solutions for Business Transformation-DC, Grand Hyatt, Washington, D.C.
November 18, 2008

Building Sustainable Business Models in a Green World, The Willard Hotel 1401 PA Ave., NW Washington, DC
November 19, 2008, 8:00 AM - 10:00 AM

Security 2008, Ronald Reagan Building, Washington, DC
November 20 - November 21, 2008


 

head
fcw
issue
First Name State
Last Name Zip
Title Email